Version 73 (modified by 17 years ago) ( diff ) | ,
---|
Version 1.0 Features
Unfinished Features
Feature | Leader | Changes API? | Implementation status | Tickets |
generic relations | Jacob/Malcolm | Yes | Code move is done (Malcolm), admin support (Jacob) not done. Needs newforms-admin merge first. | |
middleware ordering | ? | No | not started | #730, #749 |
model inheritance | Malcolm | Unclear | started | |
newforms comments | Jacob | Yes | in progress | #1829, #1853, #2134, #2177, #2228, #3091, #3546, #4189 |
newforms generic views | ? | No | not started | |
root views/url reversal | ? | Yes | Not started | #2977 |
serialization | Jacob | No | feature not clearly defined | #2930, #2843, #2650, #2553 |
windows installers | ? | No | not started |
Completed Features
Feature | Leader | Changes API? | Implementation status | Tickets |
authentication | Joseph | Yes | done | |
autoescape | Malcolm | Yes | done | #2359 |
DecimalField | Malcolm | Yes | done | #2365, #200, #2519, #3238, #3324 |
newforms | Adrian | Yes | on the way | |
oracle | ? | No | done | #4140, #4186 |
test fixtures | Russ | No | done | #2333 |
Delayed Features
Feature | Leader | Changes API? | Implementation status | Tickets |
ms sql server | ? | No | no champion |
Comments about Specific Features
Serialization
#2930 has not been decided and does not include a patch.
#2843 is not changes the API only in a compatible way and there is no decision in the ticket.
#2650 is a bug and not an enhancement, and it does not include a patch but complete files (but bug fixes should go in 1.0 anyway, if possible).
#2553 proposes to make generic views respond in formats other than html, and it does not go into details nor does it include a patch. From the description it isn't clear what it actually proposes, but it looks like a compatible change.
Comments
Jacob plans to rewrite them for newforms. This change rather belongs into the category 'newforms'. Is it really necessary to rewrite the comments in 1.0? Other than the changes in admin, the comments system rewrite shouldn't directly influence the API of newforms. -- mir
Oracle
While it doesn't change APIs, having an Oracle backend is great for the 1.0 release, even if it doesn't contribute to the #1 goal. And there is great impetus behind it. Please see the Oracle Branch wiki page for technical details.
#4140 needs a design decision: should we warn or disallow database reserved words when used as column names?
#4186 is a significant limitation of Oracle and CLOB columns that can't be worked around, so we've at least documented the limitation clearly.
Root View and URL Reversal
The root view proposal was blocked by the problem of url reversal. A few possible solutions have been brought up that had some disadvantages, and nobody of the core team has commented on this.
Model Inheritance
The latest description of the API and implementation details is in this thread.
See also ModelInheritance.
Middleware ordering
We are not treating the middleware hierarchy as a stack, in the sense that if one piece of middleware short-circuits the response construction, we go right to the bottom of the pile before processing the request. We need to decide what behaviour we really want here and record it. Both the referenced tickets have good points in them and since this might slightly change request/response behaviour, it's a pre-1.0 decision if possible.