LiveServerTestCase returns a 404 on all URLs when MEDIA_URL = '' and DEBUG = True
|Reported by:||aaugustin||Owned by:||gchp|
|Has patch:||yes||Needs documentation:||no|
|Needs tests:||no||Patch needs improvement:||no|
This is a fairly obscure bug and it was interesting to diagnose ;-)
I ran into it while working on the Django Debug Toolbar. Since the DDT isn't displayed when DEBUG = False, its tests run with DEBUG = True. I admit that this isn't a common use case. (Of course, I could change the function that controls whether the toolbar is shown to display it during tests regardless of DEBUG. But this isn't the point.) Since the toolbar doesn't handle any uploaded files, MEDIA_URL isn't set and defaults to the empty string.
In these circumstances, _MediaFilesHandler.should_handle(path) will always return True because any path starts with the empty string. Then _MediaFilesHandler.get_response(request) will fail to find the media file corresponding to path and catch the resulting Http404. When DEBUG = False, get_response will continue after the try/except block and call the parent get_response, which will return the expected result. But when DEBUG = True, get_response will happily return the 404 debug page! NB: all the code I've described is actually in StaticFilesHandler, which _MediaFilesHandler inherits.
I believe there are actually two bugs here:
- _MediaFilesHandler shouldn't be applied when MEDIA_URL isn't set — and while we're there, StaticFilesHandler shouldn't be applied either when STATIC_URL isn't set.
- get_response shouldn't swallow Http404 exceptions when DEBUG = False — this behavior has hidden the previous problem until now.
Change History (6)
Changed 2 years ago by aaugustin
comment:4 Changed 18 months ago by gchp
- Has patch set
- Owner changed from nobody to gchp
- Status changed from new to assigned