Incorrect separators when chaining floatformat to intcomma in some locales

[c.schmitt@…]

When u use floatvalue "2" and intcomma together in a template the output of intcomma won't be internationalized.

Since intcomma wont work with decimals in django 1.5.1 i tried to convert a decimal to a float in a template, but it wont give me the excepted output.
When i have the value of 1000.11 it should be 1000,11 in germany, with intcomma(float(1000,11)) i get 1.000,11. But when i use Decimal(1000,11)|floatvalue"2"|intcomma, i will get 1,000,11. Thats a bug or maybe an unwanted behavior.

[merb]

Replying to c.schmitt@…:

When u use floatvalue "2" and intcomma together in a template the output of intcomma won't be internationalized.

Since intcomma wont work with decimals in django 1.5.1 i tried to convert a decimal to a float in a template, but it wont give me the excepted output.
When i have the value of 1000.11 it should be 1000,11 in germany, with intcomma(float(1000,11)) i get 1.000,11. But when i use Decimal(1000,11)|floatvalue"2"|intcomma, i will get 1,000,11. Thats a bug or maybe an unwanted behavior.

i meant floatformat not floatvalue.

[merb]

This is the actual humanize function:

@register.filter(is_safe=True)
def intcomma(value, use_l10n=True):
    """
    Converts an integer to a string containing commas every three digits.
    For example, 3000 becomes '3,000' and 45000 becomes '45,000'.
    """
    if settings.USE_L10N and use_l10n:
        try:
            if not isinstance(value, float):
                value = int(value)
        except (TypeError, ValueError):
            return intcomma(value, False)
        else:
            return number_format(value, force_grouping=True)
    orig = force_text(value)
    new = re.sub("^(-?\d+)(\d{3})", '\g<1>,\g<2>', orig)
    if orig == new:
        return new
    else:
        return intcomma(new, use_l10n)

The problem is that floatformat returns a SafeText type, so it isn't a instance of float and intcomma gets recalled with use_l10n=False. So this line gets called:

    new = re.sub("^(-?\d+)(\d{3})", '\g<1>,\g<2>', orig)

This line will add an , to every 3rd place on the SafeText type so a string of:
1000,11 or 1000000,11 will be
1,000,11 or 1,000,000,11 which could get converted to an integer, so the next time intcomma gets called, it thinks that the SafeText type could now get converted to an integer and will then return himself.
So this will be an uncorrect return value it should return either the correct output of 1.000.000,11 or nothing since it isn't a valid number. But i think its better to check if isinstance(value, int) and if not it should check if isinstance(value, float) and when nothing is correct it should try to convert to float

Even this won't fix it: ​https://github.com/django/django/pull/785/files
Maybe its better to change floatformat to output Decimal

[Claude Paroz]

Basically, the issue is that both intcomma and floatformat take numbers (or number-convertible values) to output a string representation. So chaining them is basically broken. One strategy would be to try harder to make those string representation transformed back to numbers, but then the first transformation would be lost.

I'm of the opinion that either one of these filters should be able to do all necessary transformations. For example, we could imagine that the floatformat argument takes an optional g suffix to indicate grouping. So the result of Decimal(1000,11)|floatvalue:"2g" would be 1.000,11 for German (i.e. numberformat would be passed force_grouping=True in floatformat filter).

[merb]

wouldn't it be better to make them type safe? Like raise an error if intcomma or floatformat won't get 'numbers' or 'localized_numbers'?

[Petr Dlouhý]

This is still problem in Django 1.10.

[Alexey]

Should we try to parse value to float?

Something like try to find float separator with regex, and convert it before isinstance check

[Ronny Vedrilla]

For the specific German case a fix:

'|'.join(intcomma(floatformat(amount, 2)).rsplit(',', 1)).replace(',', '.').replace('|', ',')

Maybe this helps anybody...

In my opinion a currency-filter with optional thousand separators would solve this issue for most people.

[Mariusz Felisiak]

​PR

[Jacob Walls]

​PR

[Jacob Walls]

Addressed reviews.

[Mariusz Felisiak <felisiak.mariusz@…>]

In ac6c426:

Fixed #20601 -- Allowed forcing format with thousand separators in floatformat filter.

Thanks Claude Paroz and Nick Pope for reviews.

[Cassiano R. N. dos Santos]

Is this fixed for Django 2.2?

Doing

{{ variable | intcomma | floatformat:2 }}

or

{{ variable | floatformat:2 | intcomma }}

does not work.

In the first case results broken, and in second, gives, e.g. 1,000,00 when the correct would be 1.000,00 for pt-BR (brazilian portuguese).

[Mariusz Felisiak]

Replying to Cassiano R. N. dos Santos:

Is this fixed for Django 2.2?

No, it's fixed in Django 3.2+.

[Cassiano R. N. dos Santos]

I'm just trying the fix in Django 4.0.1 with both

{{ variable | intcomma | floatformat:2 }}  {# breaks template #}

and

{{ variable | floatformat:2 | intcomma }}  {# results i.e., 10,123,00 (would be 10.123,00) #}

But the bug persists.

In my settings.py:

LANGUAGE_CODE = 'pt-BR'
USE_I18N = True
USE_L10N = True

[Mariusz Felisiak]

Replying to Cassiano R. N. dos Santos:

But the bug persists.

I don't see the "g" suffix in your example. Also in Django 4.0 the floatformat template filter no longer depends on the USE_L10N setting and always returns localized output. Have you tried {{ variable | floatformat:"2g" }}?

[Cassiano R. N. dos Santos]

Oh, that was it. It was missing the "2g". Thank you very much.