django-admin startapp with trailing slash in directory name results in error

[jooadam]

Bash tab-completion appends trailing slashes to directory names. django-admin startapp name directory/ results in the error:

CommandError: '' is not a valid app directory. Please make sure the directory is a valid identifier.

The error is caused by ​line 77 of django/core/management/templates.py by calling basename() on the path with no consideration for a trailing slash:

self.validate_name(os.path.basename(target), 'directory')

Removing potential trailing slashes would solve the problem:

self.validate_name(os.path.basename(target.rstrip(os.sep)), 'directory')

[Carlton Gibson]

OK, yes, this seems a case we could handle.

I didn't look into exactly why but it works for startproject:

$ django-admin startproject ticket32734 testing/

Thanks for the report. Do you fancy making a PR?

[Rohith P R]

I didn't look into exactly why but it works for startproject

This is the relevant piece of code:

if app_or_project == 'app':
    self.validate_name(os.path.basename(target), 'directory')

The changes were made here: ​https://github.com/django/django/pull/11270/files

[jooadam]

Replying to Rohith P R:

Rohith, sorry for not assigning it to me first, I just submitted a pull request: ​https://github.com/django/django/pull/14383

[Rohith P R]

Hey @jooadam! I already had a [PR](​https://github.com/django/django/pull/14382) open to fix this issue. I left a comment on your PR btw. :)

[jooadam]

Replying to Rohith P R:

Hey @jooadam! I already had a [PR](​https://github.com/django/django/pull/14382) open to fix this issue. I left a comment on your PR btw. :)

Yeah, I saw it after the fact :/

[Mariusz Felisiak]

Regression in fc9566d42daf28cdaa25a5db1b5ade253ceb064f.

[Mariusz Felisiak <felisiak.mariusz@…>]

In 530f58ca:

Fixed #32734 -- Fixed validation of startapp's directory with trailing slash.

Regression in fc9566d42daf28cdaa25a5db1b5ade253ceb064f.

[jooadam]

Replying to Mariusz Felisiak <felisiak.mariusz@…>:

Mariusz, just wanted to say that I spent about four hours on my first contribution to the project, that you just completely threw away here. I probably won’t have a second.

[Simon Charette]

jooadam, it's a shame that your contributing experience was not great and to hear that your considering not repeating the experience but please be fair to Mariusz here.

There was a miscommunication between multiple parties interested in helping due to the lack of prior assignment of an owner and Mariusz has little do to with that. I'm pretty sure Rohith also invested quite a lot of time in getting his solution ready to address an an easy picking issue and followed the contributing guidelines and in the end only a single patch can land.

I sincerely hope you reconsider your decision that your realize these hours were not completely thrown away as you've certainly learned a few things about the contributing process along the way.

[dotuser]

Does any plan backport ​https://github.com/django/django/pull/11270 and ​https://github.com/django/django/pull/14382 to branch stable/2.2.x and stable/3.2.x.

# https://github.com/django/django/pull/11270
(base) root@69faeb96:/tmp/123321/django# git branch -a --contains fc9566d42daf28cdaa25a5db1b5ade253ceb064f
* main
  stable/3.2.x
  remotes/origin/HEAD -> origin/main
  remotes/origin/main
  remotes/origin/make-zoneinfo-default-timezone-implementation
  remotes/origin/stable/3.0.x
  remotes/origin/stable/3.1.x
  remotes/origin/stable/3.2.x

# https://github.com/django/django/pull/14382
(base) root@69faeb96-0f43-442b-ad2d-3e5cfa31f6d5:/tmp/123321/django# git branch -a --contains 530f58caaa5052e9e56bf8461caee4d821953bcb
* main
  remotes/origin/HEAD -> origin/main
  remotes/origin/main
  remotes/origin/make-zoneinfo-default-timezone-implementation

Or, startapp will crash bug since PR ​https://github.com/django/django/pull/11270:

(base) root@69faeb96:/tmp# /tmp/venv/bin/python -m django --version
3.2.6
(base) root@69faeb96:/tmp# /tmp/venv/bin/python -m django startproject my_project -v3 && cd my_project
Rendering project template files with extensions: .py
Rendering project template files with filenames:
Creating /tmp/my_project/manage.py
Creating /tmp/my_project/my_project/__init__.py
Creating /tmp/my_project/my_project/asgi.py
Creating /tmp/my_project/my_project/settings.py
Creating /tmp/my_project/my_project/urls.py
Creating /tmp/my_project/my_project/wsgi.py

(base) root@69faeb96:/tmp/my_project# mkdir -p my_app && cd my_app
(base) root@69faeb96:/tmp/my_project/my_app# /tmp/venv/bin/python -m django startapp my_app . -v3
CommandError: '.' is not a valid app directory. Please make sure the directory is a valid identifier.

However, that's ok if startapp with other same method:

(base) root@69faeb96:/tmp/my_project/my_app# cd ..
(base) root@69faeb96:/tmp/my_project# ls
manage.py  my_app  my_project
(base) root@69faeb96:/tmp/my_project# rm -rf my_app/
(base) root@69faeb96:/tmp/my_project# ls
manage.py  my_project
(base) root@69faeb96:/tmp/my_project# /tmp/venv/bin/python -m django startapp my_app  -v3
Rendering app template files with extensions: .py
Rendering app template files with filenames:
Creating /tmp/my_project/my_app/__init__.py
Creating /tmp/my_project/my_app/admin.py
Creating /tmp/my_project/my_app/apps.py
Creating /tmp/my_project/my_app/models.py
Creating /tmp/my_project/my_app/tests.py
Creating /tmp/my_project/my_app/views.py
Creating /tmp/my_project/my_app/migrations/__init__.py